A Geek’s Dilemma (Nokia 5800 vs Sony Xperia)

Last week, I bought a Nokia 5800.

I’ve installed everything useful, including Garmin XT. It works like charm and I was in love, until today. A guy from Lowyat.net private messaged me, letting go of his Birthday gift, a Sony Xperia.

It is only sane to reject Xperia the offer, as I have a new baby, however there’s a twist. It’s an original set retailed at RM2.5k (at least). He only wants RM1.6k. After much consideration, I went ahead and emptied my wallet to fetch the spanking new unit. It’s hard to resist that kind of offer.

5800-vs-xperia.jpg

Now I’m sitting here, contemplating. Whatever it is, one have to go.

Nokia 5800 is downright simple, everything is where it is. Xperia on the other hand, is complex and a little too much for a user who only wants to Call, SMS and GPS. Dissing elegance and value, it comes down to user experience. What do I really want?

The last tough decision I made was back in ’05, breaking up. Now, I can’t believe I have to choose whom I want to be married to for the next 2-3 years.

Is this considered one of the crossroads in life? Harder than I thought.

ps: Treated mom to some fancy Arabic cuisine. I was so full, I had to remain seated for 20 minutes. Talk about nafsu!

pss: It’s NOT my intention to materialize girls. So don’t take it the wrong way

 

There are 49 Comments for “A Geek’s Dilemma (Nokia 5800 vs Sony Xperia)”

kalo aku pilih Nokia,sbb i’m not a fan of phone yg leh lipat,leh bukak sana sini,tolak atas-bawah…sbb xpercaya benda tu leh tahan lama 😀
lagi satu, it collects dust!

but Nokia tu nampak bulky plak dr gamba tu..haih

Reply to This comment


jipo wrote on May 12, 2009 #1

Dont worry, I know exactly what you should do!

Pegi solat istikarah, pastu tido. Then, i jamin mimpi tu mesti suruh you poskan the nokia one to me lol

p/s : oh lamenye tak masok ini belog. 😮

Reply to This comment


lyana wrote on May 12, 2009 #2

pergh giler argh.. xperia dgan 5800 memang tough giler dilema ni.. ohoho semoga berjaya memilih… :halo:

Reply to This comment


topo wrote on May 12, 2009 #3

ni mak-mak dtg nk membebel…

pakai saja apa yg ada…. kalau nak dikejar byk benda yg kita nak dlm hidup ni

Reply to This comment


NoktahHitam replied #1

Baik la mak.. Sambil tertunduk penuh kesipuan :sad: :sad:

Reply to This comment


Kujie replied #1

hahahaha…. awet muda la dok gelak dpn pc je

You just made my day!

Reply to This comment


Kujie wrote on May 12, 2009 #4

vote for the might all-in-one! yeah! 😮

Function is not just about beauty. It’s how you need it.

Reply to This comment


NoktahHitam replied #1

Some of the function maybe you don’t even need. Like touch scroll gallery. Other than beauty and hogging your RAM, nothing much can be salvaged. It’s just like toggling left or right, except cooler.

Reply to This comment


alone replied #1

uh uh. i see :roll:

Reply to This comment


alone wrote on May 12, 2009 #5

lalala. pilih la Nokia tu.. tak pun pilih Samsung Android walaupun x keluar lagi. lalalaa~

Reply to This comment


NoktahHitam replied #1

Ade G1, played with it. Still ‘mentah’. 😮

Reply to This comment


bongkersz replied #1

How about Sony Idou? :p

Reply to This comment


abdusfauzi wrote on May 12, 2009 #6

Sell me the Xperia then :p I played with Nokia 5800 before, I just feel browsing and typing on it is a pain in the ass, but over time that should be fine as you get used to it. Other that that, everything is good. Give me a phone will keyboard/keypad anytime. Xperia is really a mean machine.

Reply to This comment


NoktahHitam replied #1

Bong, it’s heavy. Typing makes it tough actually. Nokia typing is fast and very light. For someone who doesnt like to exert much force like myself, Nokia is the way to go.

Probably need to familiarize with the phone first. One thing about Windows Mobile, no shortcut. Or maybe I don’t know the how to’s

Reply to This comment


bongkersz replied #1

Ah, there! I am exactly opposite. I prefer my phone a bit heavy to ‘feel’ the presence, I never really like those ‘tiny, small’ phones when it was the hit. Nokia 5800 feels like a plastic toy in my hands..

Reply to This comment


bongkersz wrote on May 12, 2009 #7

bukan ke xperia xda 3G capability ke..?? hurmm..

Reply to This comment


NoktahHitam replied #1

Ade. Siap HSDPA 7.2mb lagi. But who needs video call? Unless you have a horny gf who wants to do some sick stunts over the phone, that’ll be a different story.

Reply to This comment


nikillas replied #1

but for me, i need the 3G++ capability bcoz i always use it to vcall my family and send mms via it.. hah..!! 1 more.. mentality of malaysia people.. the more power the camera of the phone, the more powerful the phone is.. esh3.. soalan yang pasti timbul kalau dapat phone baru.. “berapa megapixel camera tu..??” aduih~!

Reply to This comment


nikillas replied #1

haha.. almost terlupa.. if i were u.. i will pilih the XPERIA.. hehe..

Reply to This comment


NoktahHitam replied #1

I’m more inclined towards Nokia now.


bongkersz replied #1

Er, you can video call me. Hahahaha! I video call my parents, and girls.. 😛

Reply to This comment


nikillas wrote on May 12, 2009 #8

Oh ya, if you want all the shits that can be used with your 5800, let me know.. hehe.. Symbian phones.. so addictive, with so many applications to choose from.

Reply to This comment


Syam replied #1

Use N70 lah like me. U can SMS, MMS, Video Call, email & most important… U can make porn movie with it. Wahahaha!

ps: Where are you Bong? Sarawak or KL?

Reply to This comment


bongkersz wrote on May 12, 2009 #9

HTC Touch Pro!!!!!!

Reply to This comment


Aisyah replied #1

that’s my phone! and I hate it. HAHA.

Reply to This comment


Zuriani Y. replied #1

kenapa tak suka? i’m planning to get one for me. tak best eh?

Reply to This comment


Aisyah replied #1

well, ramai kata best. but it’s just that, too much functions for me. I use phone to call, sms, and mms je. take photos tu pun sometimes je kalau xde camera.

tp yg bestnya memory byk gila, I dont even have to delete my messages. hoho xD


Zuriani Y. replied #1

tapi tapi ianya sexeeeeey. jual u punya kat i!

sebenarnya sayang, mana2 mobile phone yang ada memory card, semua boleh simpan messages banyak. =P


Zuriani Y. wrote on May 12, 2009 #10

talk about nafsu, it’s ‘why can’t i have both?’ question.
haha
but for me, the tube is good enough..

Reply to This comment


sub wrote on May 12, 2009 #11

i’ll choose nokia. look simple and elegant.. thats my style. :)

Reply to This comment


dawiecool wrote on May 12, 2009 #12

aisyahkama wrote on May 12, 2009 #13

i’ll choose Xperia simply because I’ve been boycotting Nokia for years…n would like to stick to it..

Reply to This comment


NoktahHitam replied #1

Woot.. Dah beli nak buat macam mane 😳

Reply to This comment


bulan wrote on May 12, 2009 #14

fuyoo!!
dua-dua gue suka…
nice blog!!!
hehheeee

Reply to This comment


mie wrote on May 12, 2009 #15

Samsung Android FTW !!!
erm .. back to ur exact question .. if i were u .. i will be using the sony ..

Reply to This comment


oDiN wrote on May 12, 2009 #16

camera xperia mmg best, tap to autofocus *woot*, design pun nampak mewah..

dump dua2, try HTC Touch HD..heh atau iphone 😛

Reply to This comment


NoktahHitam replied #1

HTC Touch HD > Gile battery

iPhone > Never on wishlist. Macam semua orang dah ade. Cool factor down. Plus, itu technology 2 tahun lepas. Bole GPS tak mae?

Reply to This comment


Mohd Ismail replied #1

stylus + windows mobile dah wujud bertahun sebelum iphone ada.. dan, 5800 lagi ramai user sbb diaorg settle mudah utk touchscreen.. asal ada..

*iphone ni xde offline map.. kene store sendiri via third party apps.. tp accuracy Google Maps terjamin :)*

Reply to This comment


NoktahHitam replied #1

Waahh.. tapi mati la nak subscribe data plan plak. Takpe lah. Aku still sayang kan duit aku dari bayar bulan2 kt ISP padahal tak pakai sgt pon.


Mohd Ismail wrote on May 12, 2009 #17

sony experia!

tapi risau lak kalau sony ni sama ngn lain2 model sony yang lain, they tend to get slower in time. :sad:

Reply to This comment


NoktahHitam replied #1

My W800 works marvelously. It’s about 3 years old and the battery life is 3-4 days. Which is pretty awesome 😀

Reply to This comment


aishah wrote on May 13, 2009 #18

oooh, arabic cuisine memang sangat kenyang. hoho. jom jom, where’s my sushi. haha.

i vote for nokia. lagi cun bebeh! kalau tanak nokia tu, bagi I pun, I sanggup terima. hehe..

Reply to This comment


NoktahHitam replied #1

Jom la sushi! You yg tak set the time and place. Obviously takde sushi in SA.

Reply to This comment


Aisyah wrote on May 13, 2009 #19

aku xpernah test xperia,so i’ll go with 5800.game racing die,aku suka!so, jual mane?5800 kah?

Reply to This comment


NoktahHitam replied #1

Still inconclusive. At the moment, letting go Xperia.

Reply to This comment


M-I-N wrote on May 13, 2009 #20

[…] = “http://www.noktahhitam.com/flirting-with-xperia.html”; I’m still contemplating over Xperia and 5800. I can’t possibly have two good phones at hand. It would be an injustice to my […]

[…] I’ve managed to sell the Xperia. Now I’m bursting with […]


Bye Bye Xperia | Noktah Hitam wrote on May 20, 2009 #22

seriously, i have my 5800 ,4 month old.it s a gorgeous machine. Cost half of xperia or an iphone. But what u want from a phone is in 5800. It s a really2 friendly user phone that comes with wifi ,gps(i use garmin..really2 amazing),opera and nokia photo browser beta is awesome! speaker is really2 loud and great!
I hv my friend use omnia, but after months,he just use 20% of the phone. He got laptop, so why the hell he need to use windows mobile?summore 5800 also have wifi,can open microsoft document,pdf,zip.one more..the video recorder is absolute significant.but not for camera . worst than omnia. but still way better than iphone.

my friend got iphone, the apps is great, includ the game.the sensor is great..but many games is hard to play..then later leave it there. only use for notes,music,sms,call,camera,website. hey! 5800 is wayyy better la..

*1 tips..store ur files in memory card, not in ur phone memory.otherwise ur phone can be lag.if lag also, u can turn off the transition effects

Reply to This comment


NoktahHitam replied #1

Already sold the xperia months ago. I only need a good one hand operation phone. 5800 fits nicely. What’s best is it’s speaker. Handsomely built, the loudest and sharpest of the clan.

Reply to This comment


alianur wrote on June 7, 2009 #23

Leave a comment, I won't bite ;)

feed for comments on this post.

Login or Register if don't want to fill in the details below everytime.